lol at 3:07 where duff is playing with alexis’ pig tails..

in 1:15 to 1:20 why isnt kate sitting with the kidss?

“they looked like a rainbow vomited.”hahaha!

Ok, I sometimes question Kate’s intentions but WOW….. Jon could have at least done SOMETHNG for her birthday, had some cupcakes delivered or something, geez

i’m pretty sure jon probably helped out in the arranging of kate’s surprise. obviously the kids wouldn’t have arranged everything themselves, and kate did say that jon knew about it. besides, just because they haven’t shown us that he did something doesn’t mean that he didn’t acknowledge that it was her birthday at all.

yeah i just noticed that when i saw jons arm. ive watched this episode 3 times now and i just realized that and im like “OH! theyre sitting next to each other!” lol

Aww, so adorable. I love it when Duff’s messing with her hair in the background

Oops, by ‘her’ I mean Alexis And she’s all ‘hey!’

so true! it’s all publicity…

gotta hand it to kate she looks good!